Netbooks are a bit of technology I hadn't really been introduced to. I had seen them in doctor's offices and probably mistook them for real computers on the laps of business folk, but I have never seen them in schools. I think this technology could be a good way to get cheep computers into the classroom, but I am unsure how useful they can be. It says in the book that these netbooks were designed "to handle the kind of work that the majority of computer users spend the most time on - surfing the web, basic word processing, viewing a brief video clip, and the like." But I am unsure as to what that really means for classroom use and student learning. If all you're looking to do is get quick internet access for research or do some word processing, I think these computers could be useful for a cheep way to have a mobile computer lab, but it's really nothing like a computer. Or so it sounds.
I have to say that for all the technology that has been developed, I'm rather on the fence when it comes to assimilating it all into the classroom. In the book it talks about there being three main concerns for netbooks: "network security, size, and system capabilities." Personally I'm not concerned about size. I'd be more concerned that there is no way for a teacher to control where students were going on the internet and that it is so basic that there are no other programs that can be added to it so that the probable lack of internet cannot be made up for and word processing becomes it's only capability. I do like having computers in the classroom for occasional use and added learning experiences. But I don't like trying to use computers every day for everything possible. Yes, it's important to teach students about technology and proper use, but it's also important for them to learn how to write and spell without the help of a word processor or spell check. It's important for students to learn how to use books as references. It's important to get students away from the internet to see how they can live life without it and still get along in this day and age. In short, I am a proponent and I am not. If I can choose when students have netbooks and when they don't, I think I could be.
Netbooks have the same pro as they do con, they are extremely limited. Limitations mean that you can't add applications you want and it is not easily altered or updated. Limitations also mean that students cannot misuse them as easily as they could a normal computer or iPad. Just like an iPad they are portable, light weight, and easy to use. iPads, on the other hand, are very customizable and controllable. The biggest problem is that they are expensive and not specifically designed for students/children, unlike the netbooks. I have to say that I like both for very different reasons. Netbooks are simplistic and mostly worry free; they also have a keyboard and a track pad. iPads have a lot of exciting applications to use, which are very interactive. Either or both could be great depending on how they were to be used in the classroom.